After announcing the award of four electric buses through the EPA’s Clean School Bus Program, we’ve received an overwhelmingly positive response from the community. Understandably, there have also been some questions and concerns, which are expected with any new technology. Below, we aim to address the most common inquiries to provide greater clarity and reassurance.
Common Questions and Answers:
Question 1: How much will the district pay for charging stations?
Answer: Nothing. The EPA grant covers the cost of the four electric buses and provides three charging stations at no cost to the district. These stations will be installed in key locations: the West Union attendance area, the District Bus Garage in the North Adams attendance area, and the Peebles attendance area. Installation, performed by a certified EV charging station company, is also fully covered by the grant. There are no hidden costs for the district.
Question 2: Could the funds for electric buses have been used for other district needs?
Answer: No. The EPA’s Clean School Bus Program provides grant funding specifically for electric buses, chargers, and infrastructure related to supporting electric vehicles. These funds cannot be diverted to other projects or operational needs within the district. The program's purpose is to promote clean, energy-efficient transportation for schools, reduce reliance on fossil fuels, and lower emissions.
Question 3: Will the electric buses have problems during Adams County’s winter weather?
Answer: No. Electric buses are designed to function in cold climates and are widely used in regions with harsher winters than ours. Lion Electric, the company supplying our buses, is based in St. Jerome, Canada, where temperatures can be significantly lower than in Adams County. The company also manufactures buses in Chicago, Illinois, and these vehicles have been proven to operate successfully in northern cities across Michigan, Wisconsin, and other cold-weather areas.
Furthermore, our charging stations have battery heaters to ensure the buses remain operational in freezing temperatures, much like the block heaters used for our current diesel buses. This technology helps maintain battery life and efficiency, even during winter.
Question 4: Are electric buses more prone to fires or other safety risks?
Answer: No. Electric vehicles (EVs) are statistically LESS likely to catch fire than gasoline-powered vehicles. A study by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) found that EVs catch fire at a rate of 1 per 38,000 vehicles, compared to 1 in 1,300 for gas-powered vehicles.
Additionally, the electric buses we receive will be equipped with advanced safety features, including nine external sensors that will automatically shut down the high-voltage system in the event of a collision. The buses are designed with passenger safety in mind. Lion Electric provides free local training for emergency first responders, ensuring they are fully equipped to handle any unlikely emergencies involving EVs.
Question 5: Who will service the electric buses, and is maintenance more difficult or expensive?
Answer: The electric buses have a five-year warranty, and the batteries are covered for eight years. In terms of maintenance, electric vehicles generally require less upkeep than their gasoline or diesel counterparts because they have fewer moving parts. There’s no need for oil changes, exhaust system repairs, or fuel system maintenance, which are routine in conventional buses.
Moreover, these buses are equipped with remote diagnostic systems, allowing the manufacturer to monitor their condition when plugged into the charging stations. The manufacturer can often detect and address potential issues remotely, sometimes even before the district is aware, leading to preemptive repairs and minimizing downtime.
Question 6: Given electricity costs, Won’t operating electric buses be expensive?
Answer: No. Electric vehicles are typically cheaper to operate than gasoline or diesel-powered vehicles. For example, a 2018 University of Michigan study found that the average annual cost to fuel an electric vehicle was $485, compared to $1,117 for a gas-powered vehicle. While electricity rates can fluctuate, the overall energy cost for EVs remains significantly lower than traditional buses.
Electric buses are also more efficient, converting about 59-62% of the electrical energy from the grid into power at the wheels, compared to only 17-21% for gasoline vehicles. This efficiency further reduces operating costs.
Question 7: Are there additional advantages to electric buses?
Answer: Yes, many. Electric buses produce zero tailpipe emissions, which means no harmful exhaust fumes around students as they board or wait for the bus. This improvement in air quality is significant for children, who are more susceptible to the effects of air pollution.
In addition, electric buses are much quieter than diesel buses, which helps drivers stay more focused and aware of their surroundings. Reduced noise pollution also makes for a calmer environment inside the bus, improving safety and communication between the driver and students.
Lastly, electric buses contribute to long-term sustainability efforts. By reducing the district’s reliance on fossil fuels, we are doing our part to protect the environment for future generations.
Question 8: Is the Adams County School District fully committing to electric buses?
Answer: No. We are not transitioning our entire fleet to electric buses. The district operates 36 bus routes, and the grant provides four electric buses. The majority of our fleet will remain diesel-powered for the time being. This initiative allows us to explore the benefits of electric buses with no additional cost to the district, helping us make informed decisions about the future of our transportation system.
________________
Conclusion:
It’s normal to feel apprehensive about new technologies, and many of the questions we’re hearing reflect common concerns. However, electric buses have been tested and proven in other districts nationwide, including areas with harsher climates and more demanding road conditions. Electric buses represent a positive step forward for the district with their cost-saving potential, improved safety features, and environmental benefits.
I hope this document addresses some of the concerns and clarifies the advantages of electric buses. We will keep the community informed and involved as we move forward with this exciting opportunity.